Is the Community College Still the Best Bet for Working-Class Students?

Recently, a friend asked me whether I’d encourage my own children (if I had them) to attend a community college, the system where I teach sociology. I said “yes” immediately, but I know what thoughts lay behind her question. She was alluding to my grumbling about research that I’d been reading that suggests working-class institutions such as community colleges may not be the best place for working-class students. Though I initially said “yes” to my friend’s question, the more honest answer is “maybe.” I feel guilty saying this, but I feel ambivalent. I am a proud community college graduate, and teaching at a community college is wonderful, but the community college does have problems that make me wonder whether we are doing right by working-class students and upholding our mission to create pathways to success.

The research around student success suggests that community colleges do not challenge students and have low expectations. In the status hierarchy of higher ed, this means community college classes are perceived as “easier,” or less academically rigorous. Moreover, research shows that students who transfer from community colleges have frighteningly low graduation rates from four-year schools — an average of just 36% complete a four-year degree within 6 years. The analysis implies that the low graduation rate might be because community colleges do not foster cultures of achievement and that students do not feel motivated to succeed.

I cannot argue with the facts, much as they frustrate me, but there are other things going on. For example, many of these schools, like mine, have limited funds available to cover the costs of their expanding enrollments, even though, the California State University system has raised their fees and limited their enrollment for the next semester…again. That creates problems with class size, among other things. In my little notch of the world, increasing enrollment means that I will allow more students than I should to add my classes.

For about the past three years, community college faculty in California have received an email at the beginning of every semester about managing the increasing number of students in our classrooms. We’re encouraged to “hang in there” and understand that the system does not have additional funds to support these extra students. Lack of funding also means we are offering fewer sections of courses and less variety of courses, even as we enroll more students.

There will be heavy competition for seats the first week of school, which makes me worry that working-class students trying to add classes at the last minute but who can’t pay their tuition immediately might lose seats to someone who can pay that day. Whatever their reason for being there—to prepare to transfer to a four-year for a degree or for workforce development—the majority of students trying to get in need my class because their class schedules must be just so, to fit in between work and family responsibilities. Schedules that “fit” are important.

I worry about options for working-class students. I am concerned about low graduation rates, large class sizes, and rising fees, but I disagree with much of the research about the quality of community college education. First, it is a myth that classes at a community college are easier and that teachers have lower expectations then at a four-year university. I teach the same intro sociology course at the community college and the local four-year university, and students’ grades are similar in both groups.

Because community colleges serve a more diverse body of students, from those who want to transfer to a four-year school to students who want to learn to read better or gain job skills, people assume that we must have lower standards. We serve all levels of preparedness, but we are seen as less academic than our university neighbors are. The reality is that community colleges offer several levels of rigor, from honors courses to developmental reading and math. Students with lopsided skill sets–for example, proficient in math but not English–catch up in one area while taking more challenging courses in another.

Second, community college instructors focus on teaching instead of research, which is part of why we are not defined as “scholars” in the eyes of the system. For the academically vulnerable working-class student, however, this means more one-on-one time and an emphasis on the student-teacher relationship, which research suggests may have more of an effect on long-term student success than anything else we teachers do. Many students have written me after transferring to say how much they miss their relationships with their community college instructors not because four-year profs are “mean,” but because they have different responsibilities that leave less time for chatting about personal lives and asking about family.

Finally, the community college costs considerably less than a four-year school, which makes it easier for students to access education. Our slogan could be, “We’re ready when you are,” but that is not academic enough. Still, for working-class students, the community college is a valued cost saving option, students can graduate or transfer after two years with very little or no student loan debt. Yes, some students graduate/transfer from a two-year without debt, they piece together money from work, a grant or scholarship, and do a lot of financial juggling, but they do it and are proud to say so. When my colleagues from the four-year school wonder why their working-class students are “so stressed” all the time or miss school because they cannot miss work I think, “They don’t get it, but we do.”

In spite of my ambivalence, I say “yes,” I would encourage my hypothetical child to attend a community college and my main reason is simple: we get it. We teach students the same material but the education costs less and the teachers want to build relationships with our students. For the working class, community college is a first step, a pathway to improving one’s position; a practical choice in the midst of record high unemployment rates and ever-decreasing labor options for high school graduates. The success of working-class students is influenced by the academic culture and the kind of connections they make. Despite the community colleges’ institutional woes, those of us that teach there know that it is in the day-to-day interactions, calling students by name and lingering for after class conversations, that we create pathways to success.

Julie Garza-Withers

Julie Garza-Withers teaches Sociology at Butte Community College

About these ads

7 responses to “Is the Community College Still the Best Bet for Working-Class Students?

  1. I attended a community college years ago…and have transfered to a great University, went on to get my Masters and am doing ok. Not awesome, but ok. I enjoyed your view point on this entry but I wanted to add to the positives of starting out at a CC. I was a big partier and social butterfly in HS. I was not challenged and simply didn’t really care about my grades, average B student anyway. I went to a CC to sit down and focus on my studies. I moved out with money I saved working for 5 years while in school combined with money from my graduation party and loans. I knew if I went to any Universities my friends did, even the more prestigious ones I’d just end of not being focused and probably do poorly. The smaller class sizes and others genuinely interested in bettering themselves in a field…not just attending college undecided or to follow the social norms, really helped me get me self together and even better, I moved to a new town where I was forced to make new friends – good ones. And when it comes to cost, this is obvious! I would encourge my children to go to a community college, take classes and try internships if they are undecided and set up a transfer program. BBA, MBA in Marketing and Advertising? From the University of… yes you paid and took hard classes everywhere, its all the same. :)

    Like

  2. Pingback: USW Blog » Blog Archive » Expanding Inequality

  3. Pingback: Community College Spotlight | CC is good bet for working-class students

  4. Thanks for this post, its helping me to think about differences across educational institutions. Can you link us to the research that you’re citing about performance in community colleges etc.?
    “The research around student success suggests that community colleges do not challenge students and have low expectations.”

    Like

  5. Pingback: Ethnography.com » Blog Archive » Working Class, Upper Class, Community Colleges, and Harvard U.

  6. Hi Julie:
    I agree with Bart: well-said! having noted that, I also lament the fact that I do not advise my kids or their friends to go to the CC in order to transfer. Transfer policies from the CC to 4-year is far too chaotic, at least in California. And, as you note this results in low transfer rates, delays in graduation for those who do graduate.

    I look forward to hearing more from you about this!

    Tony

    Like

  7. Well said, Julie. I do have to admit the statistic “an average of just 36% complete a four-year degree within 6 years.” had me concerned, but then I got it together and realized there are so many reasons for that.

    I am a byproduct of a community college that transferred to a university and went on to simply crush a 4 year degree into 10 years of school…I literally lived on drilling rigs in the oilfield and drove to Houston to attend classes then back to the rigs to do homework between crises.

    Knowing what I know about community colleges (my son is attending one) I wonder if the statistic asks whether or not community college attendees from working class families didn’t have to leave after a while to help the family out? Yes, surprise, surprise, some people do still have a sense of family and obligation. Finances and merely making a living play a huge part in the working class’ decision as to where to attend and when.

    As to motivation, a lot of that has to come from within a student, and can be equally bolstered or squashed by anyone in their family or academia. Encouragement, however, can come from anyone at anytime. I changed from a biology major to geology because of a junior college teacher, and am glad I did. To suggest that community colleges do not challenge or encourage people is simply off the mark. I fondly remember the one on one time I had with my CC teachers. And I remember the teachers and classes that caused me to re-think about my priorities vis-a-vis partying vs. GPA. Turns out there is an inverse relationship (a mathematical term I learned in a community junior college).

    Thank you for addressing this issue.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s